Subscribe Menu

How Estonia and Canada Are Fighting Honey Fraud

For thousands of years, honey has been regarded as something almost magical.Ancient Egyptians placed it in tombs as an offering to the gods, while Greek mythology associated it with immortality and divine nourishment. Often called “the nectar of the gods,” honey has symbolised health, prosperity, and even eternal life across cultures. But what if the golden sweetness in your jar is not quite what it claims to be?

Photo by Arwin Neil Baichoo on unsplash.com

Some products sold as honey have been diluted or mixed with cheaper plant-based syrups. This adulteration threatens consumers, honest beekeepers, and trust in food labels. Syrups made from corn, rice, sugar beet, or cane can be cheaper. Adding them increases a product’s volume while it may still be sold as honey, undercutting beekeepers and misleading shoppers.

Honey isn’t one uniform substance. It consists mainly of glucose and fructose, but also contains smaller amounts of other sugars, amino acids, and trace compounds that give honey its distinctive characteristics.

That natural variation makes testing complicated. Added syrups can be chosen to resemble honey’s main sugars, so scientists look for subtler clues, such as the chemical composition of a sample or traces of the organisms involved in its production.

One approach to overcome this challenge comes from Estonia, where researchers have turned to an unexpected source of information through DNA. Honey can contain tiny traces of genetic material from plants, bees, and other organisms encountered during its production. Sequencing this material creates a DNA profile, much like a fingerprint, offering clues about a sample’s composition and production environment.

This method, called metagenomic DNA analysis, examines millions of DNA fragments rather than searching for just one organism. Researchers at the Tartu-based Competence Centre on Health Technologies, working with Estonian beekeepers, report that it can help assess honey’s authenticity and origin, while also identifying bee-related pathogens and parasites. The approach has helped reveal suspected honey fraud in European markets that earlier targeted tests had missed. The research team has also explored analysing RNA, a related molecule, to detect viruses affecting honeybees.

Under Canadian rules, adding foreign sugars to a product sold as honey is adulteration.

Canada’s approach relies on chemical clues. Canadian researchers have been exploring how nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, or NMR, can be used to examine honey’s chemical composition and detect adulteration. When exposed to a strong magnetic field, different molecules produce characteristic signals, which an NMR machine records as a spectrum, essentially a chemical fingerprint of the honey.

In a 2023 study, researchers from the National Research Council of Canada, Dalhousie University, and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency examined numerous samples collected during two national surveys, to distinguish Canadian honey from samples originating elsewhere. Compounds including trigonelline and proline emerged as potential markers. Although the study focused primarily on geographical origin rather than directly detecting added syrups, it demonstrated how NMR can be used to establish detailed chemical profiles of honey.

Beyond research, NMR also has a practical role in Canada’s official honey-testing programme. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency uses it alongside stable isotope ratio analysis (SIRA) to detect added foreign sugars. While SIRA is particularly useful for identifying sugars from corn and cane, NMR can detect a wider range, including syrups from rice, beet, barley, and wheat. Under Canadian rules, adding foreign sugars to a product sold as honey is adulteration. DNA sequencing reveals biological traces associated with honey, while NMR measures its chemical composition and identifies patterns that do not fit expectations. Although the two approaches examine different clues, they share the same goal of making it harder for adulterated honey to pass as genuine.

The message for consumers is encouraging, because scientists are finding increasingly sophisticated ways to check what is in the jar. What might seem like an ordinary spoonful of honey can reveal a surprising amount when examined at the molecular level. Protecting genuine honey means protecting beekeepers, maintaining consumer trust and, ultimately, keeping the promise on the label sweet and simple.

This article was written by Emma Nahkor as part of the Local Journalism Initiative.

Read more