In a Quill & Quire review of The Canadian Writer’s Market, it was said that being a freelance writer in Canada is a good way to starve to death slowly. Does that adage apply equally to Estonia (with a population of 1.3 million) and Canada (41 million as reported by Statistics Canada in 2026)?
For starters, the comparison is only being made between living English-language Canadian writers and living Estonian writers.
In Canada, superstar writers earn a good living. Joseph Boyden, Lawrence Hill, Yann Martel, Rohinton Mistry, Michael Ondaatje, and Miriam Toews earn substantial annual incomes from advances and rights sales. I’m purposefully leaving out Canada’s literary megastar (and two-time Booker Prize winner) Margaret Atwood, who is in a class of her own. Canada’s superstar writers earn advances of six figures (CAD) but advances are paid up front as an advance against future royalties; the author receives further royalty payments only after the book “earns out” the advance.

Much of the following information has been reviewed with Maarja Kangro, the Chairperson of the Estonian Writers Union, the 355-member strong organization representing writers in Estonia. Perhaps comparable in Canada to the Writers’ Union of Canada.
In Estonia, the earning potential for superstar writers is quite different. A decade ago, the list of Estonian superstar writers would have been made up of three men: Tõnu Õnnepalu—who attended Kotkajärve Metsaülikool in 2018 and wrote a book about it, called Aaker, or “Acre” in English—Indrek Hargla (medieval murder mysteries), and Andrus Kivirähk—a beloved writer who wrote Estonia’s most popular hit since re-independence, a satirical novel called Rehepapp, with reputed sales in excess of 20,000 copies.

However, in the past four to five years, Estonian women have led fiction writing, with the younger generation represented by Lilli Luuk and Kairi Look, and in poetry, the reigning icon Doris Kareva.

What do writers earn in Canada and Estonia?
What do Estonian superstar writers earn? The unexpected answer is, about the same as a regular writer of fiction. Advances are structured differently in Estonia. An advance from a publisher only comes from a successful application to the Cultural Endowment of Estonia (Kultuurkapital, also known as “Kulka”). For prose, Cultural Endowment of Estonia scholarships range from 3,000 to 6,000 EUR. This whole amount would go to a writer as the advance, via a publisher. It would be exceedingly rare that a publisher would top up this amount. In Estonia, this is not offset by a percentage of book sales. That means if the usual percentage of sales is 10-15% (but in many cases, publishers pay nothing from the sales), that amount is in addition to the advance. In other words, the advance paid to Estonia’s most successful writers is miniscule compared to advances paid to Canada’s top authors. Although advances in Canada are confidential, it has slipped out that Canadian writer Yann Martel’s advance for Beatrice and Virgil was about 2–3 million USD.
How does the average Estonian writer’s 10-15% of sales compare to Canadian writers’ numbers?
For beginner or mid-range fiction authors in Canada, advances range from zero to 15,000 CAD (source: Reader’s Digest) and writers with track records receive up to 50,000 CAD. Advances are usually paid in installments (signing, delivery, publication) and are recouped against royalties (legalclarity.org).
The common form of payment for authors of fiction is royalties (i.e. a percentage of each book’s sale price). Approximate royalty rates in Canada are:
- hardcover (print): 10–15% of retail price
- trade paperback: 7.5–10% of retail price.
- mass‑market paperback: 6–8% of retail price
- e‑book: 20–25% of publisher’s net receipts (or sometimes 25% of cover price)
In the broadest of brush strokes, royalties in Estonia and Canada are similar in terms of percentage of sales.
In Estonia, it is very rare for a novel to be sold for film rights (the exception to the rule being Indrek Hargla’s three-part “Pharmacist Melchior” series). If the rights to a novel are transferred, more often than not, it’s to turn a novel into play. The request for film rights is usually made by students studying to be directors and who have no money to pay for its usage.
Every year, the Estonian Ministry of Culture has a jury of writers pick five writers (for a three-year term) who will receive a scholarship from the ministry… The idea is that this would provide a writer a minimal subsistence level, allowing them to focus on writing.
Any Canadian citizen or permanent resident who meets standard professional criteria—such as having a recognized body of work—can apply for grants through the Canada Council for the Arts, as well as competitive provincial and municipal arts councils. In Estonia, the government funds a small number of writers. Every year, the Estonian Ministry of Culture has a jury of writers pick five writers (for a three-year term) who will receive a scholarship from the ministry, an amount that is 1.1 times a “cultural worker’s” minimum salary. The idea is that this would provide a writer a minimal subsistence level, allowing them to focus on writing. Estonian Writers Union Chairperson Maarja Kangro thought the idea good in principle, but that the amount of the scholarship should be a little bigger. In addition to that, the Estonian Cultural Endowment pays a scholarship of 8,400 EUR a year to forty-five writers.
Number of copies published
In Estonia, a typical first printing for fiction would mean 800 to 1,000 copies. A successful first printing would mean 1,500 copies. For poetry, the average number of copies sold is in the range of 300-500 copies. Meanwhile, Doris Kareva’s poetry books have print runs of around 3,000 copies. Print numbers are accurate in Estonia, as when a novel is funded by the Cultural Endowment of Estonia, they require print (not sales) numbers to be made public.
In Canada, a first printing of 3,000 to 5,000 copies is considered perfectly respectable for a serious literary novel, with up to 10,000 copies for a recognized author. Publishers consider sale numbers to be a trade secret and, therefore, accurate information is much harder to come by.
Print runs have clearly come down from days gone by. In Estonia, during the bad old Soviet days, the number of titles that went to print was small, but print runs were large. For example, children’s books by Leelo Tungal would sell 40,000 copies. Publishers like Eesti Raamat and Valgus were state owned. These numbers have not been seen since re-independence (1991).
Since 2000, the print numbers for fiction have been falling in Canada and Western markets. Reasons include e-books, audiobooks, and streaming, with competition for time spent reading coming from the internet, social media, and video games.
Publishing in Canada and Estonia
The “big five” international conglomerates all publish in Canada as well. They are: Penguin Random House Canada, HarperCollins Canada, Simon & Schuster Canada, Hachette Book Group Canada, and Macmillan Publishers. Estimates are that approximately 70% of the English-language book market (by sales) is covered by the big international conglomerates, 25% is covered by the Canadian-owned independent publishers, and less than 5% are self-published titles.
In Estonia, the novel publishing market is covered primarily by two publishers (“kirjastused” in Estonian), Varrak and Tänapäev.
As many authors in Estonia do not see publishers giving authors strong support or PR services, they are opting to self-publish (like Chairperson Maarja Kangro). Kangro noted that even if she self-publishes and asks for 20 EUR per novel, the book store will add a mark-up of 100%, so that the sale price of the novel in the bookstore is 40.00 EUR.
When Kangro was asked why there is no paperback fiction in Estonia, she replied that the first hardcover print usually covers the demand for the novel and there is insufficient demand for a secondary offering as a paperback. And if there’s a second printing, readers expect it to be in hardcover as well.
To answer the question posed at the beginning of this article: all writers in Estonia and most writers in Canada earn, at best, a modest living, and only a small handful of superstar writers in Canada make a good living.
